Inhalt
Aktueller Ordner:
/modal15_grenze_en.tex
% Options for packages loaded elsewhere
\PassOptionsToPackage{unicode}{hyperref}
\PassOptionsToPackage{hyphens}{url}
\documentclass[
]{article}
\usepackage{xcolor}
\usepackage{amsmath,amssymb}
\setcounter{secnumdepth}{-\maxdimen} % remove section numbering
\usepackage{iftex}
\ifPDFTeX
\usepackage[T1]{fontenc}
\usepackage[utf8]{inputenc}
\usepackage{textcomp} % provide euro and other symbols
\else % if luatex or xetex
\usepackage{unicode-math} % this also loads fontspec
\defaultfontfeatures{Scale=MatchLowercase}
\defaultfontfeatures[\rmfamily]{Ligatures=TeX,Scale=1}
\fi
\usepackage{lmodern}
\ifPDFTeX\else
% xetex/luatex font selection
\fi
% Use upquote if available, for straight quotes in verbatim environments
\IfFileExists{upquote.sty}{\usepackage{upquote}}{}
\IfFileExists{microtype.sty}{% use microtype if available
\usepackage[]{microtype}
\UseMicrotypeSet[protrusion]{basicmath} % disable protrusion for tt fonts
}{}
\makeatletter
\@ifundefined{KOMAClassName}{% if non-KOMA class
\IfFileExists{parskip.sty}{%
\usepackage{parskip}
}{% else
\setlength{\parindent}{0pt}
\setlength{\parskip}{6pt plus 2pt minus 1pt}}
}{% if KOMA class
\KOMAoptions{parskip=half}}
\makeatother
\setlength{\emergencystretch}{3em} % prevent overfull lines
\providecommand{\tightlist}{%
\setlength{\itemsep}{0pt}\setlength{\parskip}{0pt}}
\usepackage{bookmark}
\IfFileExists{xurl.sty}{\usepackage{xurl}}{} % add URL line breaks if available
\urlstyle{same}
\hypersetup{
pdftitle={The Limit of the Formal},
pdfauthor={Paul Koop},
hidelinks,
pdfcreator={LaTeX via pandoc}}
\title{The Limit of the Formal}
\usepackage{etoolbox}
\makeatletter
\providecommand{\subtitle}[1]{% add subtitle to \maketitle
\apptocmd{\@title}{\par {\large #1 \par}}{}{}
}
\makeatother
\subtitle{Modal 15 --- What Modal Logic Cannot Show, Explained in the
Style of a Chess Journalist}
\author{Paul Koop}
\date{}
\begin{document}
\maketitle
\section{Preliminary Note: How to Read This
File}\label{preliminary-note-how-to-read-this-file}
This file explains \textbf{Modal 15}: the limit of the formal. In
Modules 5--14 the Trinity was unfolded as a formal structure. But formal
work has a \textbf{limit}. Modal 15 draws the consequence: It
distinguishes strictly between three levels --- \textbf{proving},
\textbf{suggesting}, \textbf{not reaching}.
It is written in the \textbf{same style} as the previous files: move by
move, with symbol explanation at every step, with plain language for
every statement.
\textbf{What is presupposed:} The files on Modal 5--14 should have been
read. In particular, the metalogical results from these modules are
presupposed as known.
\textbf{What this file achieves:} It shows three things:
\begin{enumerate}
\def\labelenumi{\arabic{enumi}.}
\tightlist
\item
Modal logic can \textbf{prove} the necessity of the Trinity
\textbf{under assumptions}.
\item
It \textbf{cannot justify} the \textbf{choice of assumptions}.
\item
This limit is \textbf{structurally related} to GΓΆdel's incompleteness
theorems --- not because S5 would be incomplete (it is complete), but
because every formal system cannot fully justify its own foundations.
\end{enumerate}
\begin{center}\rule{0.5\linewidth}{0.5pt}\end{center}
\section{Part I --- The Three Levels}\label{part-i-the-three-levels}
\subsection{1. The Picture Behind the Three
Levels}\label{the-picture-behind-the-three-levels}
Before I introduce the three levels, I give the \textbf{picture} behind
them:
\begin{verbatim}
βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
β Level 1: PROVING β
β (derivable results) β
β β certain β
βββββββββββββββ¬ββββββββββββββββ
β
βββββββββββββββΌββββββββββββββββ
β Level 2: SUGGESTING β
β (plausible interpretation) β
β β probable β
βββββββββββββββ¬ββββββββββββββββ
β
βββββββββββββββΌββββββββββββββββ
β Level 3: NOT REACHING β
β (external questions) β
β β open β
βββββββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{The picture in plain language:} Imagine a \textbf{microscope}.
On the lowest level you see \textbf{clearly and distinctly} --- that is
the level of proving. On the middle level you see \textbf{blurred} ---
that is the level of suggesting. On the highest level you see
\textbf{nothing at all} --- that is the level of not reaching.
\subsection{2. The Three Levels in Plain
Language}\label{the-three-levels-in-plain-language}
\textbf{Level 1: Proving.}
\begin{verbatim}
What is derivable in a formal system.
Status: certain (within the system).
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{Level 2: Suggesting.}
\begin{verbatim}
What becomes plausible through the formal results, but is not proven.
Status: probable (not certain).
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{Level 3: Not Reaching.}
\begin{verbatim}
What lies outside formal work.
Status: open (not formally reachable).
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{Important:} The three levels are \textbf{hierarchical}. What is
shown on Level 1 can be \textbf{suggested} on Level 2. What lies on
Level 3 \textbf{cannot} be reached by formal work.
\subsection{3. The Methodological
Self-Restriction}\label{the-methodological-self-restriction}
\textbf{The methodological self-restriction in plain language:} The
present treatise does \textbf{not} show that the Trinity exists. It does
\textbf{not} show that the axioms are true. It does \textbf{not} show
that formal work is the only mode of access.
\textbf{It only shows:} Formal work has a \textbf{certain reach} --- and
a \textbf{certain limit}.
\begin{center}\rule{0.5\linewidth}{0.5pt}\end{center}
\section{Part II --- What Modal Logic Proves (Level
1)}\label{part-ii-what-modal-logic-proves-level-1}
\subsection{1. The Metalogical Results from Modal
5--14}\label{the-metalogical-results-from-modal-514}
\textbf{The metalogical results in formulas:}
\begin{verbatim}
From Modal 5: S5 β¬ β‘βx Tr(x)
S5+SP β’ β‘βx Tr(x)
From Modal 6: {ASP2} β’ ASP1 (in S5)
{ASP3, ASP4, ASP5} β’ β‘βx Tr(x) (minimal)
From Modal 7: S5+TOP β’ β‘βx Tr(x)
S5+TEMP β’ β‘βx Tr(x)
S5+MER β’ β‘βx Tr(x)
From Modal 8: S5+SP+L β’ β‘(U β§ T β§ S)
From Modal 9: There are consistent bimodal models with Ξ© β β
From Modal 10: S5+U1+U2+U3 β’ β‘βc (Consciousness(c) β βResurrection(c))
From Modal 11: S5+T1+T2+T3+T4 β’ β‘(Z(U β§ T β§ S) β§ N(U β§ T β§ S))
From Modal 12: S5+A1 β’ Evil is not a limit
From Modal 13: S5+SP+B1+B2+B3+B4 β’ β‘(U β§ T β§ S)
From Modal 14: S5+A1 β’ β‘K(U, T, S)
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{Symbol explanation:}
\begin{itemize}
\tightlist
\item
\texttt{β’}: ``is derivable''.
\item
\texttt{β¬}: ``is not derivable''.
\item
\texttt{β‘}: necessity.
\item
\texttt{βx}: for all x.
\item
\texttt{Tr(x)}: the Trinity holds for x.
\item
\texttt{β§}: conjunction.
\item
\texttt{U}, \texttt{T}, \texttt{S}: the three limits.
\item
\texttt{K(U,\ T,\ S)}: the unity of the three limits.
\item
\texttt{Ξ©}: the Omega Point.
\end{itemize}
\textbf{In plain language:} These results are on \textbf{Level 1} ---
they are \textbf{proven}. They are \textbf{certain} within the
respective formal system.
\subsection{2. What These Results
Achieve}\label{what-these-results-achieve}
\textbf{What these results achieve in plain language:}
\begin{verbatim}
(1) The Trinity follows under certain assumptions.
(2) The assumptions are independent.
(3) The Trinity is axiom-invariant.
(4) The Trinity is formulable in different languages.
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{This is the strength of formal work.}
\subsection{3. What These Results Do Not
Achieve}\label{what-these-results-do-not-achieve}
\textbf{What these results do not achieve in plain language:}
\begin{verbatim}
(1) That the axioms are true.
(2) That the Trinity exists.
(3) That the choice of axioms is justified.
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{This is the limit of formal work.}
\begin{center}\rule{0.5\linewidth}{0.5pt}\end{center}
\section{Part III --- What Modal Logic Suggests (Level
2)}\label{part-iii-what-modal-logic-suggests-level-2}
\subsection{1. The Metaphysical
Interpretations}\label{the-metaphysical-interpretations}
\textbf{The metaphysical interpretations in plain language:} The
metalogical results \textbf{suggest} certain metaphysical
interpretations:
\begin{verbatim}
(1) The Trinity is a structure, not an object. (Modal 8)
(2) The Trinity is the only limit structure. (Modal 12)
(3) The Trinity is observer-conception-invariant. (Modal 13)
(4) The unity of perspectives is constitutive. (Modal 14)
\end{verbatim}
\subsection{2. What ``Suggesting'' Means}\label{what-suggesting-means}
\textbf{What ``suggesting'' means in plain language:} ``Suggesting'' is
\textbf{not} ``proving''. What is suggested is:
\begin{verbatim}
(1) plausible, but not compelling.
(2) compatible with the formal results, but not required.
(3) in need of interpretation β the interpretation is not determined
by the form.
\end{verbatim}
\subsection{3. The Consequence}\label{the-consequence}
\textbf{The consequence in plain language:} From the formal results
\textbf{does not follow} the metaphysical interpretation. The
interpretation is an \textbf{additional} decision.
\textbf{Formally:} The metalogical results are \textbf{compatible} with
several metaphysical interpretations. The choice of interpretation is
\textbf{not} determined by the form.
\subsection{4. The Open Questions}\label{the-open-questions}
\textbf{The open questions in plain language:} What modal logic suggests
is \textbf{not unique}. There are:
\begin{verbatim}
(1) Alternative interpretations β what in one interpretation is
called "structure" can in another be called "substance".
(2) Indeterminate concepts β what "consciousness", "death",
"integration" mean is not formally determined.
(3) Open questions β many questions (e.g., whether there are paths
that do not reach the Omega Point) are not decided.
\end{verbatim}
\begin{center}\rule{0.5\linewidth}{0.5pt}\end{center}
\section{Part IV --- What Modal Logic Does Not Reach (Level
3)}\label{part-iv-what-modal-logic-does-not-reach-level-3}
\subsection{1. The Choice of Axioms}\label{the-choice-of-axioms}
\textbf{The choice of axioms in plain language:} The central limit of
modal logic is: It cannot justify the \textbf{choice of axioms}.
\textbf{Formally:} The metalogical results show only: \textbf{If} one
accepts certain axioms, \textbf{then} the Trinity follows. They do
\textbf{not} show: \textbf{That} one should accept these axioms.
\textbf{The consequence:} The choice of axioms is \textbf{not} a
metalogical question. It is a \textbf{metaphysical}, \textbf{physical},
or \textbf{hermeneutic} question.
\subsection{2. The Three Aspects of Axiom
Choice}\label{the-three-aspects-of-axiom-choice}
\textbf{The three aspects in plain language:}
\begin{verbatim}
Aspect 1: Metaphysical choice.
Which metaphysical basic concepts does one use?
(superposition, topology, temporality, mereology)
Aspect 2: Physical choice.
Which physical interpretation does one prefer?
(Copenhagen, MWI)
Aspect 3: Hermeneutic choice.
Which interpretation of the formal results does one choose?
(structural, substantial)
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{The consequence:} The axiom choice is \textbf{not} determined by
the form. It is a \textbf{decision} that lies outside formal work.
\subsection{3. The Limit between Perspective and
Structure}\label{the-limit-between-perspective-and-structure}
\textbf{The central insight in plain language:} \textbf{What appears
from the perspective of a path as intervention is, from the perspective
of S, structure.}
This insight from Modal 10 and Modal 16 marks a \textbf{fundamental
limit} of formal work:
\begin{verbatim}
From the perspective of a path: Integration appears as future, as
intervention, as grace.
From the perspective of S: Integration is always already
happened, is structure, is
necessity.
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{Formally:} The two perspectives are \textbf{not compatible}
(Modal 9). They are \textbf{simultaneously true}.
\textbf{The consequence:} Formal work can describe \textbf{both}
perspectives. It \textbf{cannot} decide which is \textbf{the right one}.
\subsection{4. The Relation to Physics}\label{the-relation-to-physics}
\textbf{The relation to physics in plain language:} Formal work
\textbf{cannot replace} physics. It can:
\begin{verbatim}
(1) Describe structures that are physically realizable.
(2) Show dependencies between axioms.
(3) Explicate consequences of assumptions.
\end{verbatim}
It \textbf{cannot}:
\begin{verbatim}
(1) Answer empirical questions.
(2) Make experimental predictions.
(3) Identify physical mechanisms.
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{The consequence:} Physics is an \textbf{autonomous} discipline.
Formal work is a \textbf{preparation} for it, not its
\textbf{replacement}.
\subsection{5. The Relation to Theology}\label{the-relation-to-theology}
\textbf{The relation to theology in plain language:} Formal work
\textbf{cannot replace} theology. It can:
\begin{verbatim}
(1) Describe structures that are theologically interpretable.
(2) Show dependencies between axioms.
(3) Explicate consequences of assumptions.
\end{verbatim}
It \textbf{cannot}:
\begin{verbatim}
(1) Decide questions of faith.
(2) Test revelation.
(3) Answer hermeneutic questions.
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{The consequence:} Theology is an \textbf{autonomous} discipline.
Formal work is a \textbf{preparation} for it, not its
\textbf{replacement}.
\begin{center}\rule{0.5\linewidth}{0.5pt}\end{center}
\section{Part V --- The Limit between Perspective and
Structure}\label{part-v-the-limit-between-perspective-and-structure}
\subsection{1. The Central Insight}\label{the-central-insight}
\textbf{The central insight in plain language:} \textbf{What appears
from the perspective of a path as intervention is, from the perspective
of S, structure.}
This insight is \textbf{fundamental} for understanding formal work:
\begin{verbatim}
(1) Formal work operates on a certain level β the level of structure.
(2) The perspective of a single path is not identical with the
structure.
(3) The difference between perspective and structure is not formally
cancelable.
\end{verbatim}
\subsection{2. The Formal Version}\label{the-formal-version}
\textbf{The formal version in formulas:}
\begin{verbatim}
Perspective(Ξ³, Integration) β Perspective(S, Integration)
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{Symbol explanation:}
\begin{itemize}
\tightlist
\item
\texttt{Perspective(Ξ³,\ Integration)}: the perspective of the path Ξ³
on integration.
\item
\texttt{Perspective(S,\ Integration)}: the perspective of S on
integration.
\item
\texttt{β }: not equal.
\end{itemize}
\textbf{In plain language:} The two perspectives are \textbf{not
identical}. They are \textbf{simultaneously true}.
\subsection{3. The Consequences}\label{the-consequences}
\textbf{The consequences in plain language:}
\begin{verbatim}
(1) Formal work can describe both perspectives.
(2) Formal work cannot decide which is the right one.
(3) The choice of perspective is a hermeneutic decision.
\end{verbatim}
\subsection{4. The Relation to Modal 9}\label{the-relation-to-modal-9}
\textbf{The relation to Modal 9 in plain language:} In Modal 9 it was
shown: DeLillo and Van Dormael are bimodally incompatible, but
simultaneously true. The limit between perspective and structure is
\textbf{related} to this insight:
\begin{verbatim}
Perspective of a path corresponds to DeLillo (collapse, one reality).
Structure of S corresponds to Van Dormael (no collapse, all
realities).
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{The consequence:} The limit between perspective and structure is
\textbf{not} a defect of formal work. It is a \textbf{structural
property} of reality.
\begin{center}\rule{0.5\linewidth}{0.5pt}\end{center}
\section{Part VI --- Comparison with Wittgenstein, GΓΆdel,
Carnap}\label{part-vi-comparison-with-wittgenstein-guxf6del-carnap}
\subsection{1. Wittgenstein}\label{wittgenstein}
\textbf{Wittgenstein in plain language:} Wittgenstein (Tractatus)
distinguishes between what is \textbf{sayable} and what \textbf{shows
itself}. The unsayable is \textbf{not} an object of language.
\textbf{Comparison with our conception:}
\begin{verbatim}
Common: There is a limit of the formal.
Difference: For Wittgenstein, the limit is linguistic. For us, it is
structural.
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{What our conception achieves:} It avoids mysticism without
denying the limit.
\subsection{2. GΓΆdel}\label{guxf6del}
\textbf{GΓΆdel in plain language:} GΓΆdel (incompleteness theorems) shows:
Every sufficiently strong, consistent formal system contains true
statements that are not provable.
\textbf{Comparison with our conception:}
\begin{verbatim}
Common: The limit of the formal is structural.
Difference: For GΓΆdel, the limit is within the system. For us, it is
between system and application.
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{What our conception achieves:} It shows that the limit is
\textbf{not} a defect of modal logic (S5 is complete), but a
\textbf{structural} property of \textbf{every} formal system.
\textbf{Important:} The limit is \textbf{structurally related} to GΓΆdel,
but \textbf{not identical}. S5 is complete; the incompleteness lies
\textbf{not} in S5, but in the \textbf{application} to metaphysical
questions.
\subsection{3. Carnap}\label{carnap}
\textbf{Carnap in plain language:} Carnap distinguishes between
\textbf{internal} and \textbf{external} questions. Internal questions
are decidable within a linguistic framework. External questions are
\textbf{not} decidable --- they are \textbf{practical} decisions.
\textbf{Comparison with our conception:}
\begin{verbatim}
Common: The choice of axioms is an external question.
Difference: For Carnap, the external question is pragmatic. For us, it
is metaphysical, physical, or hermeneutic.
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{What our conception achieves:} It avoids pragmatism without
abandoning the distinction.
\subsection{4. The Point}\label{the-point}
\textbf{The point in plain language:} Our conception takes up elements
of all three philosophers:
\begin{verbatim}
From Wittgenstein: The limit of the sayable.
From GΓΆdel: The structural limit of the formal.
From Carnap: The distinction between internal and external
questions.
\end{verbatim}
But it differs from all three in that it grasps the limit
\textbf{structurally} --- as a \textbf{property} of formal work, not as
a \textbf{defect}.
\begin{center}\rule{0.5\linewidth}{0.5pt}\end{center}
\section{Part VII --- What Follows?}\label{part-vii-what-follows}
\subsection{1. The Central Insight}\label{the-central-insight-1}
\textbf{The central insight in plain language:} Formal work has
\textbf{done its work}. It has shown:
\begin{verbatim}
(1) What is formally provable.
(2) What is formally suggested.
(3) What is formally unreachable.
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{Formally:}
\begin{verbatim}
Proving β Suggesting β Not Reaching
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{Symbol explanation:}
\begin{itemize}
\tightlist
\item
\texttt{β}: ``is proper subset of'' (hierarchical order).
\item
\texttt{Proving}, \texttt{Suggesting}, \texttt{Not\ Reaching}: the
three levels.
\end{itemize}
\textbf{In plain language:} The three levels are \textbf{hierarchical}.
What is proven is also suggested. What is suggested is not always
proven. What is unreachable is neither proven nor suggested.
\subsection{2. The Consequences}\label{the-consequences-1}
\textbf{Consequence 1:} Formal work is \textbf{not} the last instance.
It is a \textbf{preparation}.
\textbf{Consequence 2:} Formal work is \textbf{not} the only mode of
access. It is \textbf{one among several}.
\textbf{Consequence 3:} Formal work is \textbf{not} the truth. It is a
\textbf{form} of truth.
\subsection{3. The Relation to
Tradition}\label{the-relation-to-tradition}
\textbf{The relation to tradition in plain language:} Classical
metaphysics often seeks \textbf{the} truth. The present treatise shows:
There are \textbf{several} modes of access. The formal one is
\textbf{one} among them.
\textbf{This is not relativism.} It is an \textbf{insight}: Formal work
has its \textbf{reach} and its \textbf{limit}.
\begin{center}\rule{0.5\linewidth}{0.5pt}\end{center}
\section{Part VIII --- What Remains
Open}\label{part-viii-what-remains-open}
\subsection{1. The Ten Open Questions from Modal
17}\label{the-ten-open-questions-from-modal-17}
\textbf{The ten open questions in plain language:}
\begin{verbatim}
Question 1: Is there a canonical extension of S5?
Question 2: Are there paths without Omega Point?
Question 3: What is suffering?
Question 4: Is there a third observer conception?
Question 5: Is K(U, T, S) minimal?
Question 6: How does Z relate to β‘?
Question 7: Are there perspectives that do not converge?
Question 8: Is unitarity a physical fact or a metaphysical
assumption?
Question 9: How does the formal structure relate to empirical
reality?
Question 10: What does it mean to recognize the Trinity β as
distinguished from formal proof?
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{These questions are on Level 3 --- they are not formally
reachable.}
\subsection{2. The Methodological Limit}\label{the-methodological-limit}
\textbf{The methodological limit in plain language:} The present
treatise has a \textbf{methodological limit}:
\begin{verbatim}
(1) It shows formal consequences of the axioms.
(2) It does not show whether the axioms are true.
(3) It does not show whether the Trinity exists.
\end{verbatim}
\textbf{We stand at the beginning of infinity.}
\begin{center}\rule{0.5\linewidth}{0.5pt}\end{center}
\section{Afterword}\label{afterword}
You have read this file. You have learned about the three levels ---
with symbol explanation at every step and plain language for every
statement. You have seen the metalogical results from Modal 5--14. You
have understood the limit between perspective and structure. You have
seen the comparison with Wittgenstein, GΓΆdel, and Carnap.
What remains is the insight:
\begin{verbatim}
Modal logic can prove the necessity of the Trinity under assumptions,
but it cannot justify the choice of assumptions.
This limit is structurally related to GΓΆdel's incompleteness theorems β
not because S5 would be incomplete (it is complete), but because every
formal system cannot fully justify its own foundations.
We stand at the beginning of infinity.
\end{verbatim}
The next file (Modal 16) treats \textbf{paths without Omega Point}:
structural integration.
\emph{This file was written in the spirit of strict modal logic, yet in
the language of a chess journalist --- for the proof requires both: the
precision of the formula and the vividness of the move.}
\end{document}